Can a State Assembly Reject Citizenship Amendment Bill Legally?

Blogs

Can a State Assembly Reject Citizenship Amendment Bill Legally?

13 Jan 2020
  Can a State Assembly Reject Citizenship Amendment Bill Legally?
profile_avatar
Crowdwisdom360
106

On Friday, 11th Of January 2020, Citizenship (Amendment) Act officially came into operations. A notification from the Home Ministry said that the provisions of CAA will come into force from January 10, 2020. On December 11, 2019 Indian Parliament passed the Citizenship Amendment Bill and after the accent of the President, it became an Act. However, soon after many state non-BJP state government issued a statement saying that they will not let the Act to be implemented in their state. But a question arises, “ Can a State Assembly reject the law passed by Indian Parliament Legally?”

1. As per the Constitution of India no state can go against the law passed by the Indian Parliament.

2. India is a “Union of State” and not a “Federation of States” headed by the President of India. The Prime Minister and the Council of Ministers are appointed by the President to run the Republic of India. Governor is the Head of State who is also nominated by the President.

3. President acts on the advice of the Prime Minister Of  India as per the Article 74 of the Constitution. Interestingly Indira Gandhi through 42nd amendment made it mandatory for the president to accept advice of PM & council of ministers. 

4. The 7th Schedule of Constitution divides the subjects between Union and State. It defines 3 list                                                        

  • The Union List 
  • The State List
  • The Concurrent List (Both state and Centre can make law, however Central Law will Prevail if made.)

        Citizenship Subject is at No 17 of the List, which comes under Union List.

 

                                                                             

5. According to Article 365 of the Constitution, it mandatory for the states to implement every laws made by the Parliament. As per the article a State Gov can be superseded by the   President Rule if it denies the Laws made by parliament. Read snippet.

                                                   

 

Therefore, Constitutionally state does not have power to reject the implementation of Citizenship Amendment Bill unless there is some special provisions in the Bill with respect to that state like in case of North-eastern states. If a state government refuses to implement the Act, it will lead to toppling of that Government in their respective state.

Do join our Prediction game and play the Quiz on Citizenship Amendment Act. To play the quiz click here and to join our prediction game click here.

By Aabhas Maldahiyar @Aabhas24

Rewards
Redeemable coins
0

Redeem Coins
$ 5 or equivalent
20000 coins
My Profile
Purchase History
No purchase history available
OK
Wallet History
Available Coins

4050

You won the World Cup prediction game.
Game . 16 July 2019
+ 20000
You won the World Cup prediction game.
Game . 16 July 2019
- 20000
You won the World Cup prediction game.
Game . 16 July 2019
+ 20000
You won the World Cup prediction game.
Game . 16 July 2019
+ 20000
You won the World Cup prediction game.
Game . 16 July 2019
+ 20000
Notifications
Redeem Coins
Redeemable Coins Available
0
Note : Only Coins which you earn
can be redeemed. Purchased or
Bonus Coins cannot be
redeemed.

Coins will be redeemed in 2
working days
Redeem History
Redeemable Coins Available

0500

Redeemed Points
600
01 August
05:00 PM
Redeemed Points
600
01 August
05:00 PM